| Player |
Pens |
| Willetts, J |
21^ |
| Proctor, JR |
20* |
| Hibbert |
13 |
| Hogan, RD |
11 |
| Baker, DP |
10* |
| Shoulder, A |
10* |
| Newton, R |
9* |
| Anderson, WB |
8* |
| Boyd, A |
8* |
| Houchen, KM |
8 |
| Hegarty, T |
8* |
| Miller, TW |
7 |
| Newton, JL |
7 |
| Saville, AV |
7 |
| Smith, RW |
7 |
| Fogarty, AG |
6 |
| Hedley, G |
6 |
| Ingram, SD |
6 |
| McMahon, HJ |
6 |
| Southall, LN |
6* |
| Baker |
5 |
| Dixon, KL |
5* |
| Hedley |
5 |
| Hewitt, JJ |
5 |
| Hinchliffe, J |
5 |
| Bircumshaw, A |
4 |
| Gauden, A |
4 |
| Hooper, HR |
4 |
| Lawrence, M |
4 |
| Thornton, P |
4 |
| Toman, JA |
4 |
| Wensley, H |
4 |
| Allen, JT |
3* |
| Allon, JB |
3 |
| Ayre, W |
3 |
| Barker, R |
3 |
| Barrett |
3 |
| Cooper, MN |
3 |
| Cummings, RD |
3 |
| |
| Player |
Pens |
| Fletcher |
3 |
| Goldthorpe, W |
3 |
| Hewitt |
3 |
| McEwan, S |
3 |
| Parkes, BJ |
3* |
| Phythian, ER |
3 |
| Robinson, P |
3 |
| Robinson, WA |
3 |
| Short |
3 |
| Thayne, W |
3 |
| Bamford |
2 |
| Bielby, PA |
2 |
| Brown, W |
2 |
| Clark, ID |
2 |
| Daly, J |
2 |
| Dixon, JW |
2 |
| Edgar, J |
2 |
| Ellis, K |
2* |
| Hampson, W |
2 |
| Hughes, WH |
2 |
| Hibbert, J |
2* |
| Johnson, KP |
2 |
| Linacre, P |
2 |
| Lindsay, DM |
2 |
| Luke, GT |
2 |
| Lumley, R |
2* |
| McGuigan, T |
2 |
| Musgrave, JW |
2 |
| O'Donnell, J |
2 |
| Poskett, M |
2 |
| Richardson, GW |
2* |
| Richardson, W |
2 |
| Smith, WE |
2 |
| Strachan, G |
2 |
| Clarke, D |
1 |
| Cochrane |
1 |
| Common, J |
1 |
| Crilly |
1 |
| Dalton, P |
1 |
| Davies, GP |
1 |
| |
| Player |
Pens |
| Dickenson, J |
1 |
| Dowson, F |
1 |
| English, S |
1 |
| Freestone, C |
1 |
| Gabbiadini, M |
1 |
| Hafekost |
1 |
| Hand |
1 |
| Hird, T |
1 |
| Honour, B |
1 |
| Howe |
1 |
| Humphreys |
1 |
| Jobson, JT |
1 |
| Johnrose, L |
1 |
| Johnson, K |
1 |
| Kell, G |
1 |
| Lithgo, G |
1 |
| Llewellyn, C |
1 |
| Midgley, CS |
1 |
| Mutrie, LA |
1 |
| Owens, TL |
1 |
| Porter, J |
1 |
| Reed, HD |
1 |
| Robertson, P |
1 |
| Scott |
1 |
| Scott, JC |
1 |
| Smith |
1 |
| Spelman, I |
1 |
| Spencer, T |
1 |
| Staff, P |
1 |
| Thompson, AS |
1 |
| Thompson, JE |
1 |
| Tinkler, M |
1 |
| Tither, J |
1 |
| Toward |
1 |
| Hibbert, W |
1 |
| Walsh, A |
1 |
| Watson, G |
1 |
| Wiggett, DJ |
1 |
| Wright, GC |
1 |
|
